Well when I went to my general physician a few weeks ago, and he had no issues with it, my dad said he'd go with me to see the surgeon.
From all my research, this surgeon is the best around. He says he does about 50 gynecomastia surgeries a year (been in practice since 1992), most of the other doctors I've emailed only do like 15-20 a year.
So the surgeon took some pictures, examined the tissue, talked about how it would work, and what I should know. Dad asked some questions, the doctor handled them really well, and that was pretty much it. He charges $5800 for it. I've got some quotes for $5000, but my better judgment says splurge for the extra $800 and go with the best. The doctor and the receptionist asked if I wanted to look at dates, I couldn't because I need to get the final approval from mom (she was most resistant to it, so I'll cross my fingers), but as we left the office dad told the doctor, "I'm sure you'll see us again", which was a good thing to hear. haha