I have to recommend Dr. Jacobs. He's in your neighborhood in NYC, so it wouldn't be too far for you to go for surgery and follow-up. He has an excellent reputation as a gynecomastia surgeon, and he posts very often on this site.
You should try to find a good plastic surgeon who is not too far away from your home town, if possible. Follow up visits with your surgeon are important, and the farther away your surgeon is, the more expensive it will be for you in the long run.
Hope this helps.
Dr. Pope, M.D.