AI: (duck duck AI chat)
Given your measurements and the fact that you find a 44DDD with an extender comfortable, here’s a little breakdown to help clarify your fit and potential sizing options:
Your 46 band measurement (underbust without a bra, loose) suggests around a 46 band size might be close to your natural ribcage size—though bras are often worn tighter for support.
Your bust measurement at 52 (loose fit) suggests you likely need a larger cup size than a standard DDD in a 44 band.
You wear a 44DDD (which is a 44 band, triple D cup) but use an extender, which hints that 44 may be a bit tight on the band.
Being wide set means you might benefit from styles with wider-set straps and cups that accommodate your chest shape for comfort and better fit.
Possible suggestions:
Try a 46 band size since your underbust is around 46—this will give more comfort around the ribcage without needing an extender.
Cup size based on a 46 band: Cup sizes change when band changes (sister sizes concept). If 44DDD fits well in cup volume, a 46DD or 46DDD might fit similarly. But since your bust is 52, you might want to try what cup size corresponds to 52 inches on a 46 band, possibly around 46G or so, depending on brand sizing.
Look for bras with wider wires and straps to suit your wide-set chest for better comfort and support.
Consider professional fitting or specialty brands that focus on full bust and wide-set shapes for the best fit.
Second response:
Possibly, but your measurements alone don’t confirm the fit. If 46 inches is your snug underbust and 52 inches is your bust, the 6-inch difference points roughly to a DDD/F cup in some sizing systems—but cup letters vary by brand, and measurement-based estimates are only a starting point. Also, many sizing methods round the band to an even number, so a measured 46 may suggest trying a 46 band rather than assuming 44.
tommyjohn.com
The extender is worth paying attention to: if you need one because the 44 band feels too tight, try the same cup volume in a sister size with a larger band—often 46DD when starting from 44DDD—and compare. The bra that fits best should have a band that sits level and feels snug without digging in, cups that contain the breast tissue without spilling or gaping, and wires that follow the breast root.
lavieenrose.com
1
Scooping and swooping when you put the bra on is normal, especially if you have tissue toward the sides. You shouldn’t have to keep repositioning yourself during the day. Since you say you fill the cups well, I wouldn’t automatically go up in cup size; instead, check whether the wire encloses all your tissue and whether the center front and band sit comfortably. A different cup shape or wider wires may suit your wide-set shape better than simply changing size.
vanjonssondesign.com
Third response:
That makes 44DDD with an extender sound like a reasonable fit for you in that Torrid style. A bra size isn’t determined by measurements alone, and fit can vary by brand and design. If the 46 band feels loose while the 44 is too tight on its own, using an extender to make the 44 comfortable is a practical solution—not a sign you must size up.
Since the strapless bra stays put, the cups contain your tissue after scooping and swooping, and you feel comfortable, those are good signs. Check that the band stays level and doesn’t pinch, restrict your breathing, or leave painful marks; also make sure there’s no spilling at the top or sides and the underwire, if present, isn’t resting on breast tissue. If those checks feel good, you likely have a good fit in that particular bra.