Hi Supersonic123,
I was like you and had a mild case of gynecomastia, so I know what you're going through, especially reading about some of the horror stories of guys who got disappointing results from their surgeons.
I had surgery on June 04, 2012, so I'm almost at the 2-month point. I'm very happy with my results as I'm totally flat and my chest looks much more masculine than before. Of course I'm still in the healing stages, but I am amazed at my results.
The one thing that concerned me was getting keloid scars, which are raised scars from cuts etc., that form on the skin. I get those on my chest really easily and when my surgeon saw some old ones, he made the decision to do everything through the aureola to hide the incision and deal with any scarring there. Luckily, that area where he cut hasn't developed any keloids and I can't even see the cut.
Here's what help me decide my case:
When I went in for my consultation, I asked my doctor if I were a good candidate for the surgery (excision and liposuction) and he said yes. I also asked if the benefits far outweighed any risk that I was taking and he again said yes.
We discussed what he would do for the procedure, and what would happen if I were unhappy with the results (and how much it would cost me). This is where he really put me at ease because he has a revision policy in place, and it's written down on paper when you sign the surgery consent forms, so if I were unhappy with my results, my revision surgery would only cost me $500 to cover the anesthesiologist's fee and my doctor wouldn't charge me anything.
He also had in place, injections that could be done after surgery for flattening out keloid scars, and/or anything else that might have popped up.
We also discussed some of the common problems that occur with this type of surgery like crater deformity and he told me that was due to the surgeon removing too much tissue from the chest, so his approach was to do it modestly because it's easier to go back in (if needed) to remove more tissue, than it is to correct a crater deformity.
Anyway, my point is that my doctor made me feel that he was willing to stand by his work and that he was going to be a willing and helpful partner in this endeavor. He explained everything to me fully, so that I understood what was going to happen, and he also made me feel comfortable that -- if anything went wrong or if I was unhappy with the results -- he would fix it, at minimal cost to me. I think that was the key.
Remember, there is no plastic surgeon out there who can guarantee what your outcome will be because there are so many variables going on like how you heal, how much was done, etc., etc. that they can only do the best job they can do (with what they know) and then your body takes over and does the rest. The only thing you and the doctor can do is hope for the best outcome, but make sure there's a plan B for corrections just in case.
Even if you went to a surgeon with a long list of fabulous clients with great results, doesn't mean that you'll get the same results, since every person is different, and a good doctor will tell you the same thing.
Just make sure you know where your doctor stands on revisions and how much it'll cost you if you need additional work from being unhappy with your results. Once you find that out, and it's something that you find agreeable, and you feel like the doctor will stand by his work, then go for it!
I didn't think that the results would be as dramatic as they would be, but they are. Now when I look down, I don't see the two mounds on my chest and I don't miss them at all!
Good luck, Supersonic
. None of us can tell you what to do, but we're all here to lend a hand of support so keep us posted.